Don’t go chasing waterfalls… That’s what I’m telling you, but if you’re going to do it anyway (despite TLC’s multiple warnings!), know that you can stand underneath one wearing Urban Decay’s new concealer, and your makeup would emerge completely intact.
It’s waterproof to the extreme, so keep your fave oil-based makeup remover handy, because you’ll need it to take this concealer off your face.
Extremely matte, extremely waterproof
A new addition to the UD permanent fam, All Nighter is a long-wearing, high-coverage liquid concealer available in 14 shades ($29 each).
They have a… I want to call it an ultra-matte finish, because they’re SO matte that they don’t reflect any light whatsoever on the skin, which makes them easier for me, as a woman in my 40s, to wear on my cheeks, nose, mouth, chin and forehead, but not so easy to wear under my eyes.
For some reason, matte concealers, especially the flat mattes like these, age me. I dunno, but I swear they make my fine lines look more obvious (whereas dewy/reflective concealers like Make Up For Ever’s HD and MAC Matchmaster make my under-eye area look plumper and more youthful).
Awesome for everywhere except under my eyes
If you’re 30+, I wouldn’t recommend All Nighter as an under-eye concealer, but it’s boss for everything else on your face because it covers up everything (it’s also way more pigmented than UD’s Naked Skin concealer).
It hides freckles, discoloration, redness… All Nighter handles it all, and it’ll do it all night long, even if you go for an impromptu swim at midnight (it happens). It’s waterproof and long lasting.
Also in the new Urban Decay All Nighter line…
Feels like NARS Pure Radiant
The texture is similar to NARS Pure Radiant Concealer. It has that same creamy, gliding fluffiness, so it’s super easy to blend.
I prefer to use my fingers to apply it because I think it’s easier to control that way and sticks better to the skin.
Works in place of foundation
You can pair this with Urban Decay’s All Nighter Foundation, but I think you can also easily get away with using the concealer on its own to even out your skin tone. I use just a few drops — seriously, it’s so concentrated that you won’t need more than three or four small dots for a small area, like a cheek or around your mouth — blend it with my fingers (work quickly because it dries fast!), and I usually skip powder, because I don’t think it needs it. This covers pretty much everything on its own.
Who’s it for?
I think this would be great for someone looking for a long-wearing, flat matte finish concealer to wear anywhere on their face except beneath their eyes.
I mean…you can wear it under your eyes, but I’d recommend cutting it with a drop or two of face oil to take down the matte-ness a bit if you do.
I also like this if you live anyplace with weather extremes, like someplace hot and humid like Hawaii, or someplace that gets lots of snow or rain. Or, if you just want super polished skin with a matte finish…this could work for you, too.
It’s available now in the permanent line at Ulta, Sephora and the UD website.
Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,
Karen
Sissi says
November 21st, 2017 at 7:19 pmI totally hear you on the matte concealers! Yes, also over 40 over here and matte just isn’t a very flattering look on my old skin lol! Now a pimple we want shine free covered up, of course! Haha! ?
Sissi recently posted … WUNDERLIFT 60 Second Wrinkle Reducer Review & BEFORE/AFTER PICTURES!
Karen says
November 22nd, 2017 at 9:04 amYes! I also want to cover up those post-pimple marks/discolorations. They hang around forever, it seems.
Have a nice day, Sissi! What are you up to? I’m going to the grocery to pick up the pre-made T-day meal I ordered, and then to Target to get some tupperware some our guests can take home leftovers.
Katie says
November 21st, 2017 at 8:33 pmI’m 21 and even I wouldn’t wear this under my eyes! But to be fair, I have begun wrinkling a bit “prematurely” compared to my peers. I would be interested in this for blemishes though because it looks like this isn’t going ANYWHERE once it’s on! I’ll have to check it out if/when it goes to Sephora stores. I have their Naked Skin concealer but I don’t often use it. It’s nice, just pretty heavy-duty already, so I can only imagine what this one is like.
Katie recently posted … Done!
Karen says
November 22nd, 2017 at 9:01 amHi Katie,
In the PR it said that this new one is, like, 73% more pigmented than Naked Skin. How they got that number I have no idea, LOL! But it is very much a high-coverage concealer, so yes, it will definitely cover up blemishes.
Rachel says
November 22nd, 2017 at 5:12 amI agree with you about not using matte concealer under the eye area. I have UD naked concealer that I love for under they eyes because it has a slight sheen/reflective quality to it. I use Makeup Forever concealer in other areas where I want a matte finish. It’s a little annoying to have to use 2 kinds!
Karen says
November 22nd, 2017 at 9:00 amHi Rachel,
I like that UD concealer too for the under eye area, but on me it moves sometimes (depends on the eye cream I have on). Do you use primer underneath it? Set it with a powder?
Happy Wednesday!
Rachel says
November 22nd, 2017 at 10:43 amI always set with powder. It’s not the longest lasting but it looks the best.
Karen says
November 22nd, 2017 at 4:41 pmYeah, I figured. Whenever I wear it I have to lock it down with something, anything. You might want to try Make Up For Ever’s HD one of these days. It has a similar look to it but lasts longer, I find.
Anya says
March 3rd, 2018 at 1:48 amHi Karen, thanks for your great review and swatches. I was considering the MUFE HD for under eyes. How does this compare to MUFE Full Cover concealer for the rest of the face, like blemishes etc? Is it drying as the day goes on?
LindaLibraLoca says
November 22nd, 2017 at 6:01 amI rely on my BB corrector under my eyes anyway, but this one needs to get on my face to cover my spots and scars. Should I go chasing waterfalls, but as you said, TLC warned against it…
LindaLibraLoca recently posted … Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance – 100 years too late
Karen says
November 22nd, 2017 at 8:59 amStick to the rivers and the lakes that you’re used to!
Indya says
November 22nd, 2017 at 8:08 amThis looks right up my alley. I have been using concealer a lot in lieu of foundation and it’s been working out. Those shades don’t look like a match for my skin tone though. I’m actually really surprised there are only two dark shades, with all of the competitive inclusiveness going on in the beauty industry right now. Ah well.
I remember UD having a matching foundation to these and me being very excited about it. Have you tried those?
Indya recently posted … 10 Pearl-Clutching Beauty Confessions That Make Me Rethink Life
Karen says
November 22nd, 2017 at 8:49 amHi Indya,
I was surprised to see that, too. Granted the beauty industry has come a long way since the only concealer options were light, medium-light and medium. I’m guessing that maybe they’re waiting to see if people like the line, and then they’ll add new shades. They’ve done it in the past.
Hope you’re having a nice day so far. One more day ’til turkey!
Kim says
November 22nd, 2017 at 9:53 amOh, gosh, I feel like any concealer makes my fine lines look like the Grand Canyon. I can’t imagine what this matte version would do. 🙂 To be honest, I think I’m just terrible with concealer. I only recently learned from you that it’s not to be worn under foundation/BB cream. It seems obvious now.
PS Happy Thanksgiving!!!
Karen says
November 22nd, 2017 at 1:57 pmYou crack me up, Kim! Do you have a face oil that you like around? You can always try mixing a little bit in with your concealer to thin it out a little. Set it with a tiny bit of powder afterwards, but do it immediately because timing is key.
Happy Thanksgiving to you too!
Chelsea says
November 23rd, 2017 at 3:27 pmThis’ll be a pass for me! I need a new undereye concealer for when I wear tinted sunscreen (which is a bit darker than my skintone, but translucent), but matte undereyes are bad on me. Not necessarily aging, but I have easily dried skin. I’ll probably just repurchase Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer.