The $38 Benefit Femme Metale Precious Metals Eye Makeup Kit: An Alchemist’s Delight

Published in: Makeup, Product Reviews

Benefit Femme Metale
Before the new limited-edition Benefit Femme Metale Precious Metals Eye Makeup Kit entered my life, the closest I’d come to metallic greatness was the time James Hetfield and I shared a sidewalk.

For $38, you get three full-size Creaseless Cream Eyeshadows and three large sample-size pencil liners in the Sephora exclusive kit — a headbang-worthy bargain (insert sign of the beast [HERE]), considering the Creams usually go for $19 a pop.


Femme Metale’s gilded metallic shades, new but limited edition, give the kit an almost steampunk vibe, and all six colors apply with shimmer to spare.

I’m a Creaseless Cream die-hard, and Taupe-Aztic (the shimmery golden tan), Platinum (the shimmery white) and Plum-ing For Gold (the shimmery plum) are just as pigmented and long-wearing as Birthday Suit and Skinny Jeans, my go-to faves from the permanent line.

Texture-wise, though, I think they’re a little different. These Creams feel fluffier and less dense to me — Cool Whip vs. Country Crock — which seems to make ’em easier to spread and blend.

I wonder if Benefit plans to expand the whipped texture to the rest of the permanent Creaseless Cream line; if they are, I’m totally on board! I find the texture easier to use.

The three liners are also new to Benefit and remind me A LOT of Urban Decay’s 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencils. Like those, they practically glide on my skin, depositing plenty of pigment, and don’t smudge once dry.

benefit femme metale review swatches photos box

benefit femme metale review swatches photos box closeup

benefit femme metale review swatches photos box 2

benefit femme metale review swatches photos creaseless creams closed

benefit femme metale review swatches photos creaseless creams open
Clockwise from lower left: Creaseless Cream Eyeshadows in Plum-ing for Gold, Taupe-Aztic, Platinum

benefit femme metale review swatches photos plum-ing for gold creaseless cream
Plum-ing for Gold

benefit femme metale review swatches photos taupe-aztic creaseless cream

benefit femme metale review swatches photos platinum

benefit femme metale review swatches photos pencils closeup 2

benefit femme metale review swatches photos pencils
Liners from lower left: Steel Her Date, Gem-n-eye, Blinged

benefit femme metale review swatches photos swatches-creaseless-creams
Creaseless Cream Eyeshadow Swatches from left on NC35 skin: Taupe-Aztic, Plum-ing for Gold, Platinum

benefit femme metale review swatches photos swatches-liners
Liner swatches from left: Steel Her Date, Gem-n-eye, Blinged

benefit femme metale review swatches photos swatches-all

benefit femme metale

benefit femme metale review swatches photos k2
Additional products used in this look: Benefit Sugarbomb blush on my cheeks, Benefit Silky Finish Lipstick in No Competition on my lips


With fun colors, smooth textures, excellent staying power and a fantastic price ($38), Benefit’s Femme Metale kit’s a star.

Sephora will launch Femme Metale nationwide this October, but New Yorkers won’t have to wait. The kit’s available now at the Sephora store on 34th Street! Sephora Beauty Insiders can also get it now. Makeup and Beauty Blog Rating: A+

Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,


September 11, 2001P.S. Today I can’t help but reflect on the events of another September morning nine years ago. It was one of those defining moments in time, clear and precise, and even though years have passed, I still think about it often. Take care of yourself today. Talk to you soon.


Like this post? Tell your friends!

So far, 30 people have commented on this article. How cool is that?

  1. Isabel says:

    I want it now! These colours are to die for! Great post, as always!

  2. Lisa S. says:

    love this look! I don’t have any the Creaseless Cream shadows and this might be a great entry point for me. Oooo No Competition, I had this on yesterday…..

  3. Tiffany says:

    You look cute, as always! I have this kit on it’s way to me!

    That was the day before my 18th b-day, I still remember it clearly also. Hard to believe it was 9 years ago.

  4. Nina says:

    Oh my pretty colors of the Creaseless Cream Eyeshadow … I wants! πŸ™‚

    Love the look you did w/ it … πŸ™‚

  5. Sherri says:

    Pluming for gold is gorgeous πŸ™‚
    Sherri recently posted … I found Hidden Treasure!!!!

  6. Meghan says:

    ooooo i think i have to get this, especially because theres an eyeliner called “gem n eye” which is pronounced “gemini” which my sign so thats my signal right there that i need to have this!

  7. Amber says:

    You look sharp! This set makes me wish I had less makeup. πŸ˜€

  8. Kate & Zena says:

    Between Benefit and UD, I’m going to go BROKE.

  9. Christina says:

    I like these shadows but what I’m really interested in is what foundation/powder did you use?! Your skin looks FLAWLESS yo! Do share your secret!

  10. Christy O says:

    Oh. My. Godot. I’ve been following you for years and can’t believe I never read of your James experience. I lust for that man. I assume I didn’t click on the original link as the colours are neutral and I’ve been doing bright and BRIGHT since the age of 14.
    Please post details the moment you ever see Robert Trujillo or Wayne Static. Loooove.
    Although James holds a very special place for being my first and only blond-hair crush.
    Sweet dreams to me tonight.

    Oh, and yeah, gorgeous palette!

    • Karen says:

      Ha ha! Yeah, he was literally an arm’s length away (what’s also funny is it happened to be El Hub’s second brush with Metallica… he’s also run into Lars).

  11. kirsty says:

    Ooh, this kit looks so beautiful! I got my first creaseless cream the other day (skinny jeans!) and I’m eager to try more πŸ˜€

    Is there any word on if this will be hitting UK shores?

  12. Roseline says:

    Karen! Your foundation looks amazing. Which one are you using? =]

    • Karen says:

      Hi Roseline,

      I used a combo of different things:

      1. Laura Mercier Oil-Free Foundation Primer
      2. Laura Mercier Oil-Free Foundation
      3. A 50/50 mix of MAC Prep+Prime and MAC Blot buffed into the skin with a kabuki brush

      It’s a little heavy for day-to-day wear, but this trio happens to photograph really well for me!

  13. Pinch says:

    Love love love the look of these! I’ve been meaning to try the Creaseless cream liners since forever but never gotten around to it – but these are right up my alley! πŸ™‚
    Pinch recently posted … Kitschmas with Shale and Indian Ink

  14. Kim says:

    Those are lovely and, predictably, I got excited about Platinum and Blinged. πŸ™‚

    I remember it very well; it was a completely surreal day. Our wedding was 4 days later and several people weren’t able to make it because of the flight situation, including a groomsman. It was definitely a bittersweet week.

  15. JessM says:

    Hmmm. Now I think I might get this to try the cream shadows out. I’m a UD 24/7 junkie and would love to try the liners too. I’ve never used a cream shadow before. Any tips on how to apply it? What type of brush do you use? How to blend it, how long does it take to set, etc?

  16. Alexandra says:

    Awww why cant we have sephora over here πŸ™

    Vince and Gannet send purrrs to Tabs lol

  17. Susana Felix says:

    I just love the colors… been wanting to try Creaseless Cream Eyeshadow for a while now..
    Susana Felix recently posted … Lipgloss da Nyx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge