How About a Lift from the NYX Eyebrow Push-Up Bra?

Published in: Drugstore Beauty Finds, Makeup, Product Reviews

karen of makeup and beauty blog reviews the nyx push up bra eyebrow pencil
NYX Eye Brown Push-Up Bra on brows

How do you feel about glitter brows?


My gut reaction when I saw the NYX Eyebrow Push-Up Bra pencil ($10) was a big, fat OH, HELL YEA! I’ve probably worn glitter just about everywhere else, so I figure brows won’t be that much of a stretch.

The dual-tipped Eyebrow Push-Up Bra, called that because of how it’s supposed to lift brows, is one of five fall products from NYX to shape, define and highlight eyebrows. The side with the darker tip, the one for defining sparse areas, sports a sheer taupe with silver glitter; the other side’s a creamy, peachy pink that appears to lift the brows when applied beneath the arch (also works as a brow highlighter).

nyx push up bra for eyebrow

The definer’s silver sparkles aren’t exactly what I’d call in-your-face glitter. They’re barely noticeable, really, which could either be good or bad, depending on your point of view. I was hoping for a little more oomph!, but I guess without it the pencil’s actually more wearable.

See how sharp the definer tip looks in the picture? It also feels hard against my skin, and because of how sheer the pigment is it takes several layers to adequately fill in my “ghost brows.” In other words, if you’re a fill-and-go girl, this may not be your ideal brow pencil. Yeah, it’s been a tad frustrating to use.

One advantage, however, of sheer pencils like this one is control. Lighter layers mean having more control over how light/dark you go, and if you’re a newcomer to brow filling and don’t want to look like Morticia Adams, a sheer pencil like this could be a good place to start.

I get the feeling from the taupe definer tip that NYX was trying to pick a universal shade, something that would work for most skin tones, mine not included. On me this particular taupe has a cool gray tint, and one that I’m afraid may lead strangers to refer to me as “ma’am” instead of “miss.” BOO!

The highlighting tip is much creamier and pigmented than the definer, and it looks like a total ripoff of Benefit’s High Brow Lifting Pencil ($20), except in a warmer, darker shade.

NYX was kind enough to include a few pictures with the instructions on the box (see below). Following them, I get a subtle brow lift, but every little bit helps.

If NYX sold the highlighting tip separately and charged $5 instead of $10, I’d stock up, because I think the color is a closer match to my skin tone than High Brow’s shade, and I’d be able to get four of them for $20 instead of one. Plus, I think it has a slightly more pigment, yet it’s even easier to blend.

nyx push up bra for eyebrow review box instructions

Swatches on NC35 skin: Eyebrow Push-Up Bra Brow Pencil (left) and Highlighter (right)

Eyebrow Push-Up Bra Highlighter (left) and Benefit High Brow (right)

nyx push up bra for eyebrow review eye before after final
Clockwise from upper left: naked brow; filled in brow and unblended highlighter; filled in brow with blended highlighter

Without filled brows and highlighter (left) and with (right)

If you’re interested, brace yourself for some bad news, though. I had a tough time tracking down the Eyebrow Push-Up Bra. It sold out last week on the NYX website, and according to the company won’t be available again online until mid-January (yikes!).


If you spot it somewhere, please share in the comments to help anyone reading who’d like to give it a try.

LOL, it’s like a makeup Yeti…

PRICE: $10
AVAILABILITY: Limited. Could be sold out on the NYX website through mid-January 2011

Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,



Like this post? Tell your friends!

So far, 32 people have commented on this article. How cool is that?

  1. Paris B says:

    Oh I actually found High Brow too light for me too. It sometimes gives me an unexpected look especially in photos. In real life, its not as bad… I just have to be careful not to use it when I expect photos to be taken πŸ˜› So this NYX one looks like a better option too πŸ™‚
    Paris B recently posted … Your Say- Does your hair colour affect your makeup choices

  2. Appu says:

    I am quite happy with my Milani Easy Brow.Not sure if this color is gonna suit me anyways πŸ™‚ Btw, if any one is interested, this is still available at!!!
    Appu recently posted … The Body Shop Spiced Vanilla Body Butter

  3. vonnie says:

    i don’t even see the glitter, interesting. i’d think it’d be overpowering but I don’t even see it at all
    vonnie recently posted … Are You a Marilyn or a Jackie

  4. Karen says:

    Hi everyone,

    The product’s available for purchase on the Cherry Culture website. Here’s the line for those who are interested:

    Nyx Eyebrow Push Up Bra

    Thanks to MBB reader Appu for the heads up!

  5. Hedy says:

    Anyone able to compare this to Anastasia’s Go Brow – Universal Brow Pencil ?
    Hedy recently posted … Gap Friends and Family Sale-November 2010

  6. Nina says:

    im always up to try brow products — this is promising!!!

    • Karen says:

      Hi Nina!!

      Yay, you’re back!

      Are you guys officially moved in?

      • Nina says:

        yes we are! πŸ™‚

        we got the absolute last stuff last night — whc was the stuff in the refrigerator!

        however – the hubs forgot the butter and onions in the refrigerator drawer so i was saying last night that were only 99.8% moved in. he said – let the butter go, ninaaaaa!!!

        LOL im happy to be back!

  7. hahah a glitter brow pencil…interesting concept. The highlight shade looks nice on you, what do you usually use to fill in your brows? Off the top of my head, I’m remembering MAC concrete and an angled liner brush? could be wrong…
    makeup morsels recently posted … Miscellaneous Monday Morsels 11-8-10

  8. Magi says:

    Did you sharpen the pencil already? How does it behave?

    I like the colors but I am a more brow gel gal…

  9. Kerry says:

    If you want to give this a try, check out E.L.F.’s version of this product. It’s in their studio line, so it’s $5 (I think), but I really like it!

    • Karen says:

      Hi Kerry,

      Thanks! Here’s the info for anyone who’s interested:

      ELF’s version is called the Eyebrow Lifter & Filler. It’s $3, and comes in four shades — ivory/light, ivory/medium, ivory/dark and ash/ivory.

      • Kerry says:

        Thanks for correcting me on the price — I knew $5 didn’t seem right.

        I like it so far, but to those interested, beware: The cap of the filler end tends to fall off. :/
        It’s also pretty creamy, so you don’t need a lot of pressure (which I like). And there’s a built-in sharpener.

  10. Tiffany H says:

    Interesting product. Too bad it’s sold out.
    Tiffany H recently posted … Manicure Mondays-Essie Chinchilly

  11. Kim says:

    It actually does lighten you up a bit, but I don’t like the sound of that scratchy, old-lady-eyebrow-color side. Now if they’d only come out with an eyelid lifting stick. That’s something I could get behind! πŸ™‚

  12. knownever says:

    I tend to think that those eye brightening sticks make people look older. Like I remember watching QVC or something showing before and afters with the benefit one and thinking the models looked worse after. Maybe high schoolers can get away with it but no one after that. Maybe it’s as some people said a weird reaction the product has to cameras that makes people’s skin look sort of translucent/thin ish
    knownever recently posted … Cracking the Armor- Men and Libraries

  13. Kristen says:

    I am obsessed with brow fillers, and I have to say, I would NEVER think to put glitter on my brows. I would be so hesitant to test-drive that, even though I adore glitter, but it looks fab on you! Really subtle, actually. I may have to give this pencil a whirl.
    Kristen recently posted … A Peek Inside My Makeup Bag

  14. jen says:

    I had the Anastasia Brow Go Brow which I loved and thought would be my HG until the lead in the pencil flew out of the wood and wouldn’t sharpen so it only lasted about a month before it was un-usable. Like NYX it also has the same glittery color in the filler and is also more of a lighter buildable sheer universal taupe color. The highlighter side also looks just like NYX very blendable and soft. Unlike NYX this pencil cost $21 more than twice the cost of NYX. So I’d be interested to try NYX to see if it couldnt be a cheaper dupe.

  15. YooJin says:

    oh i never noticed the glitter until this review! i don’t see any when i use it! As a very pale girl with brunette hair, i find that the colours match very well on me, but i can definitely see that it wouldn’t be universally flattering.

    also, i bought mine in store from LOFT in japan, but i just bought a new one from Amazon! The prices are marked up, but only to $12, which i don’t mind because this is the only eyebrow filler i go for!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge