Benefit They're Real Remover

Longwearing Makeup Better Look Out When Benefit They’re Real Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover Comes to Town

Published in: Daily Beauty

Benefit They're Real Remover

Benefit’s new They’re Real waterproof eye makeup remover, $18

I tried my hand (eye?) at Benefit’s new They’re Real waterproof eye makeup remover last night, saturating a cotton pad with the formula, which is kind of thick like a lotion, then wiping and rinsing.


It lifted away the waterproof They’re Real Push-Up Liner I was wearing without a hitch, but my eyes started watering when it touched my water lines.


Maybe my eyes are just sensitive to it. I might give it another try in a few days… The formula is supposed to be made for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes.

Until then, I think I’ll stick with MAC Cleanse-Off Oil for the heavy-duty stuff.

If you’re curious, look for They’re Real Remover at Benefit counters and online this July.

Benefit They're Real Remover

Back of the tube and box

Benefit They're Real Remover

Benefit They're Real Remover

The ingredients…in French


Like this post? Tell your friends!

So far, 7 people have commented on this article. How cool is that?

  1. AT first look.. i though it might be a new highlighter from Benefit.. 😉 .. I liked the prettyy black packging for the remover…

    I have faced similar issues of eye watering while using some eye liner on waterline.. I think its not made to be used on waterline.. 🙂
    Poo@beautyandmakeupmatters recently posted … 5 Simple Makeup Tricks

  2. Petra says:

    Ha! A sentence in swedish on your blog, I think that is the first I have seen (didn’t even know Benifit translated it to Swedish).

    I think I am gonna stick with some cleansing oil (cheaper – especially since I mix my own – and it gets everything with out a hitch).

    Happy Friday Karen and Tabs from a beautiful, sunny Stockholm.

  3. Divya says:

    I have had bad experiences with removers which make my eyes water.. the whole eyeliner, eye shadow go down the drain! I was hoping this will be less irritating for the eyes! I love the Clarins eye makeup remover, its great stuff
    Divya recently posted … Le Blanc De Chanel

  4. Sylirael says:

    I am still loyal to my beloved Bi-Facil, (and its Neutrogena dupe when times are leaner) 😛 Stinging or watering eyes with an eye makeup remover is kind of a bad sign, I think. Still! It might work for some!
    Sylirael recently posted … Nude Dungeoneering! The Urban Decay Naked 2 Palette Review

  5. Erin says:

    That doesn’t sound good!
    Erin recently posted … Banana Republic Marimekko Collection

  6. Fancie says:

    Hmm doesn’t sound like it’s too gentle around the eyes…
    Fancie recently posted … MAC Alluring Aquatic Haul & Swatches

  7. Ellen says:

    Clinique ‘s comforting cream cleanser takes off all makeup, even waterproof mascara, without a drop of irritation. I rub it over each eye separately and then wipe off with a wet cotton ball. Then I rub it all over my face, wipe off with tissues, and then go over my face with a wet cotton ball, or wash cloth. Follow with toner on a cotton ball if you like, and whole face cleaned, with one product! At $19.50 a tube, each one lasts about a month, with daily use.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge