Things I wish were shorter:
- Winter and the annual rainy season
- The line at the DMV
- Titanic (seriously, we already know how the story ends)
Things I wish were longer:
- Summer
- Cat lifespans (I might clone Tabs)
- The wear time of these $20 Stila Long Wear Lip Color Lipsticks
It would make sense for the 16 permanent collection members of Stila’s Long Wear Lip Color Lipstick team to last a long time, wouldn’t it? I mean, Stila went out of their way to include the words “Long Wear” in the name, and they even wrote about wear time in the official product description…
“The next revolution in lip wear is here! A lipstick and lip gloss all in one that boasts extended wear while keeping lips feeling soft and smooth – never dry. The secret is a blend of patent-pending polymers that provide long-lasting wear with rich pigment that glides on like your favorite gloss. The tip of the pen is contoured to provide easy, precise application – hugging every curve of your lip.”
With that kind of pomp and circumstance, I expected at least 5-6 hours from these — but that’s about two hours longer than they actually last. 🙁
I’ve tried three of the shades so far — Outrageous (a matte Mad Men reddish orange), Lover (a creamy deep red) and In the Nude (a creamy beige).
My eyes lit up the first time I saw them swatched on the back of my hand. “OOH!” I cried, “Look at how opaque and pigmented they are!”
I like their light vanilla fragrance, the fact that they’re unflavored and how hydrating they are, but those things are kinda offset by some negatives.
The rounded tip they talk up in the product description? Totally awkward. It’s hard to draw crisp, precise lines with it, especially along the outer edges of my lips.
Stila Long Wear Lip Color on NC35 skin from left: Lover, Outrageous, In the Nude
Lover
Outrageous
In the Nude
And I’m not crazy about the way these feel, either. I like lipsticks with a light, smooth texture, and these feel fairly heavy and thick.
At least some of them could also use a little refinement when it comes to color consistency. Both of the creamy shades (In the Nude and Lover) apply evenly, but the matte (Outrageous) looks pretty patchy to me.
But those aren’t even the most disappointment things about these. That honor goes to wear time, which is where these really let me down. I’ve been getting about four hours if meals are included, or five without; that pales in comparison to a lot of other long-wearing lip products (like the matte lip duos from Fred Farrugia).
Makeup and Beauty Blog Rating: While inconsistent across the line, a few standout colors save Stila’s Long Wear Lip Colors from the Land of Forgotten Lipsticks, but you’re taking a gamble for $20. For that price, and considering it’s a part of their name, I also think they really should last longer. Throw in a cumbersome rounded tip, and these can’t help but fall short of greatness. I’m not the biggest fan, but if you see a color you can’t live without, they might be worth taking a chance. Available at Sephora and online. Grade: B-
Have you given these a try yet? Am I just missing the point? I’d love to hear what you think.
Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,
Karen
makeup morsels says
October 11th, 2010 at 3:17 pmI think In The Nude is a gorgeous color. I guess you would probably have to use lip brushes to get a clean application though, right? gahh that’s too bad. hmm maybe I just haven’t encountered as many long-wearing lip products as you have, but to me 4 or 5 hours is pretty good. Usually when I hear “short wear time” where lip products are concerned, I think around 2-3 hours.
makeup morsels recently posted … Epic Earrings
Karen says
October 11th, 2010 at 6:45 pmHi Makeup Morsels,
For the darker colors, yes, a lip brush would probably help. It kinda defeats the purpose of convenience, though, sigh.
Shannon says
October 11th, 2010 at 3:42 pmy’know, I tried this lipstick a while back (I think the shade was coquette), and I was just…. not a fan. It didn’t have awesome staying power (I’m pretty sure it didn’t last more than 2-3 hours on me – I don’t exactly remember, though), it faded unevenly, and I don’t think it really applied that evenly, either. I did really like the rounded tip, though, and the scent. It smelled like cocoa butter and vanilla extract! yum.
Karen says
October 11th, 2010 at 6:44 pmHi Shannon,
It does smell really good… almost good enough to eat. 🙂
Appu says
October 11th, 2010 at 4:10 pmLover seems like a nice shade 🙂 But, I don’t think I’ll be getting these.Somehow, not very impressive 🙁 Plus I wouldn’t wanna pay $20 for these. These are so many better long wearing lipsticks in the market 🙂
Appu recently posted … The Body Shop Honey & Oat 3-in-1 Scrub Mask seems almost edible!
Karen says
October 11th, 2010 at 6:42 pmHi Appu,
I hear ya. What lipsticks have you had your eye on as of late?
Appu says
October 11th, 2010 at 6:54 pmI’ve been wanting to try Tarte’s Lip stains a lot of late…They don’t have the look and feel of a lip stain, so I am hoping they’ll be moisturizing enough 🙂
Appu recently posted … The Body Shop Honey & Oat 3-in-1 Scrub Mask seems almost edible!
Karen says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:24 pmI have a weakness for Tarte’s lip items. They make really great glosses. If you haven’t tried ’em yet, you need to!
Olga says
October 11th, 2010 at 4:38 pmLover looks gorgeous!!! I might give it a try 🙂
Karen says
October 11th, 2010 at 6:41 pmHi Olga,
Good luck! Let me know what you think of the rounded tip. Maybe it’ll work better for you than it did for me.
Olga says
October 11th, 2010 at 9:10 pmI think I might just cut off a bit from the top to make a nice sharp angle… Hate to waste product, but its not like I am ever going to use up a lipstick before it expires anyway 🙁
Karen says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:22 pmThat’s a good idea… I was going to see if I could sharpen it with my pencil sharpener, but cutting off the tip might waste less.
Sarahc says
October 11th, 2010 at 4:46 pmThey look great on your hand, but I concur, not that great on the lips. What made Stila think that a crayon was a good shape for the tip? lol!
Karen says
October 11th, 2010 at 6:40 pmHi Sarahc,
I dunno! I’m actually tempted to take my sharpener to the tip…
Nina says
October 11th, 2010 at 5:50 pmI dont use lipsticks often enough to justify this. Sad but true. :/
Karen says
October 11th, 2010 at 6:40 pmHi Nina,
You sound like me circa 1999-2002. Those were my “gloss years,” LOL!
How was your day? I’ve been thinking about Rice Krispie treats all day long!
Nina says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:43 amMy day was busy but flew by! 🙂
I got home, went and exercised, had oatmeal for nom and watched House. I was embarassingly asleep by 930. 😀
Im on a gloss kick these days — my current fave is the Cyndi lipglass!
Karen says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:23 pmI think I might be the only person on this earth who hasn’t seen that show. I have several friends who watch it and love it!
And WOO HOO to being in bed by 9:30. I’m actually jealous. 🙂
Tracy says
October 11th, 2010 at 6:02 pmI remember trying one of these once and wasn’t impressed either. I totally agree about the patchy application and the rounded tip being awkward. The BE Buxom Big and Healthy Lipsticks kinda’ remind me of them-but at least they have a pointed tip!
Karen says
October 11th, 2010 at 6:38 pmHi Tracy,
A pointed tip would help the situation a little… but not by much.
Do you remember if the formula was drying for you?
Tracy says
October 12th, 2010 at 8:19 pmYes-it was drying. Nothing worse than that feeling boy!
Rachael says
October 11th, 2010 at 8:06 pmThat Paramour looks pretty close to the color I usually wear. Plus I love Stila products, most of my eyeshadows are from them, nor do I go anywhere without one of their Convertible Lip and Cheek creams. I may need to try this when my friend and I go to Sephora
Rachael recently posted … Time for Cuteness
Karen says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:21 pmHi Rachael,
I’m with you on the convertible colors and the shadows — both are pretty cool!
knownever says
October 11th, 2010 at 9:44 pmThe weird crayon stick vibe of these is a major turnoff. It makes them seem like a kids’ toy version of lipstick. Lover is a quite pretty shade though.
Karen says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:20 pmYeah, I wish they’d change the tips. If they were pointy it would make a huge diff in useability!
Vonvon says
October 12th, 2010 at 2:51 amLover is such a pretty red. If I am not mistaken, they already had these in the past. Because when I saw the names of the shades, like Darling, Paramour, Flushed….I have them…..
Vonvon recently posted … EOTD-FOTD- Pink Look With NYX Strawberry Milk Jumbo Eye Pencil- Make Up For Ever Aqua Cream 5 & MUFE Fascinating Lip Gloss 16
Karen says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:19 pmHi Vonvon,
Yeah, these aren’t new… they’re part of the permanent line.
DonnaN says
October 12th, 2010 at 5:17 amDarn, had the review been better, I might have gone for Paramour, Serenade or Treasure. I’ll try to give them a swatch-shot on my next Sephora visit.
Karen says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:18 pmHi Donna,
It seems like some ladies like ’em so it’s probably worth a go. Lemme know if they end up moving you!
Kim says
October 12th, 2010 at 10:21 amI haven’t tried these, but had a Stila lip/eye pencil at one time that pretty much turned me off the brand. I guess it’s not nice to judge on one product, but I just thought it was terrible. Scratchy, uneven color and very drying. I gave it an F and never really looked at Stila again. I don’t think these lippies will be changing my mind! 🙂
Karen says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:18 pmHi Kim,
The line has changed a LOT of the last few years. It’s changed ownership and has moved into a new direction…
Back in the day I used to love their palettes. They had these really clever ones that looked like magazine covers that were so cute!
https://www.makeupandbeautyblog.com/cosmetics/wedding-palette-auditions-stila-front-cover-look-no-4/
https://www.makeupandbeautyblog.com/face-of-the-day-fotd/wedding-palette-auditions-stila-cover-look-no-2/
Kim says
October 13th, 2010 at 6:26 amThanks, Karen! I felt like I’d been a bit too harsh on Stila yesterday so I’m glad you included the links. PS Calico cats are notoriously ill-tempered. 🙂
Stephanie says
October 12th, 2010 at 11:20 amyou are so right…I ordered one of these (darling) last year and I swear it lasted no more than 20 minutes. I was horrified that it was sold as “long wear.” I have to say, Stila customer service was great about it though – I complained and they replied right away and reimbursed me for the product.
Karen says
October 12th, 2010 at 6:16 pmHi Stephanie,
That’s good to know. I really do appreciate it when companies make an effort to do good customer service. It’s hard to come by these days!
Melissa W. says
October 14th, 2010 at 7:00 pmI’m so sad these apply patchy like that as I really, really wanted the matte orange color. Who makes a good matte orange?
Melissa W. recently posted … New- Stila Natural Beauty Palette