Doesn’t it seem like more and more makeup brands are getting onto the airbrushed bandwagon? — the one filled with colorless loose powders designed to deliver an “airbrushed” look?
There’s MAC Prep+Prime, Make Up Forever HD Powder and Tarte Amazonian Clay Smooth Operator, to name but a few, and despite their different names and packaging, they promise a lot of the same things.
“[PRODUCT NAME] absorbs oil to create a matte finish, sets foundation and concealer, blurs fine lines and reduces the appearance of pores for a soft focus (read: airbrushed) look.”
The latest airbrushing beauty bit to cross my path calls itself Smashbox Photo Set Finishing Powder with SPF 15 ($28), and it airbrushes with the power of — wait for it — zinc oxide!
Zinc oxide?
Rather than being absorbed into the skin, zinc oxide, an inorganic white powder, acts as a physical sunblock, sitting atop the skin where it reflects rays of UVA and UVB light. Generally considered noncomedogenic (meaning it doesn’t block pores), zinc oxide is also a mild antimicrobial believed to accelerate wound healing. Unfortunately, products containing enough of it can look chalky on darker skin tones.
After wearing Photo Set a few times over the past week, there are some things about the product I think Smashbox really did well. First, the packaging — LOVE the wide jar, which accommodates my big powder brush without making a mess.
Second, it handles oil pretty well. With it on, even after a full day, my forehead, chin and nose (the oiliest parts of my face) are only just beginning to shine.
As for the whole soft focus effect thing, well, I don’t know. It’s hard to say. I haven’t noticed anything when I’ve been out and about, but I think I do detect slightly smoother skin in pictures. The effect isn’t as dramatic as it is with MAC Prep+Prime (which, by the way, is frickin’ fantastic), but I think it’s still there.
Smashbox Photo Set Finishing Powder SPF 15 on face
Unfortunately, Photo Set suffers from the zinc oxide curse — yep, it leaves a slight white cast on my NC35 skin. It’s subtle, though (I wouldn’t call it chalky), and lovelies with lighter skin may not even notice it at all.
But then there’s the price… At first I thought, “Cool! A big jar!” But it’s really not that big. At $28 for 0.17 ounces, Smashbox is actually charging more for less. MAC Prep+ Prime delivers 0.32 ounces for $23, Tarte Smooth Operator costs $28 for 0.32 ounces and Make Up For Ever’s HD Microfinish will set you back $30 for 0.35 oz. All of them work out to more product for less.
All told, Photo Set probably won’t be kicking my beloved MAC Prep+Prime off its pedestal any time soon (Prep+Prime also happens to be SPF 50). It’s pricey, and I’m not too keen on the white cast, but Tabs gives it two paws up for being cruelty-free. 
PRICE: $28 for a 0.17-oz. jar
AVAILABILITY: At Sephora stores and smashbox.com
MAKEUP AND BEAUTY BLOG RATING: B
Wherefore art thou, sleep?
Desperately seeking sleep!
Hello, young lady. 🙂 I got home late last night from a work dinner in SF and didn’t get to bed until 2, so I’m not feeling entirely coherent today.
Speaking of books (kidding), remember that big book of food essays I started a few days ago? I finally finished it, and now I’m really, really hungry.
I’m so hungry, in fact, that I could eat an entire carrot cake right now, no joke!
But enough about my food cravings. Howzit going today? Tell me something good.
Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,
Karen
AnieJ says
February 9th, 2011 at 4:14 pmI finished my taxes today, so while I’m skipping this powder, I’ll be skippin’ on home for a nice hot bath!! Woot woot!
AnieJ recently posted … elf Tools I Might Never Live Without Again
Karen says
February 9th, 2011 at 4:55 pmThat sounds perfect right now! Ahhh…
Tracy says
February 9th, 2011 at 4:50 pmI’m with you-nothing beats MAC Prep+Prime for me too.
I stopped for some groceries today, and bought a bag of chocolate covered almonds. Sigh. But they’re good for your heart, right? 😀
Tracy recently posted … Maybelline Volum Express One By One Mascara
Karen says
February 9th, 2011 at 4:54 pmYes they are. If they’re dark chocolate you might even be able to pass ’em off as really healthy!
Molly says
February 9th, 2011 at 5:07 pmSo excited-I just found out that the Safeway by my house has Panda raspberry licorice bars, which are like THE “candy” of my childhood. Inducing nostalgia in 3…2…yum.
Karen says
February 9th, 2011 at 5:08 pmThat’s exciting! Speaking of childhood candy, I could really do with some Mentos right now.
stacie says
February 9th, 2011 at 5:09 pmTell me something good wah wah (that supposed to be singing – I can’t read that sentence normally has to be sung!) I got an ipod touch today which is def good! Think I will become an apple fangirl 😀 I like the sound of the zinx oxide might help my blemish prone skin… will have a look into that next time I need powder xoxox
stacie recently posted … Fimo cane nail art
Karen says
February 9th, 2011 at 5:10 pmHaha, I love that song!
How are you liking your iPod Touch? I’m a certified Apple fan and am currently lusting over the Macbook Air.
Tiffany says
February 9th, 2011 at 5:30 pmI’ll stick with the prep and prime that I recently bought because you told me too! 🙂
Something good – I spent way too much cash on a Vera Bradley diaper bag and weekender bag and wristlet and I am way excited for them to arrive on my doorstep!
Karen says
February 9th, 2011 at 6:19 pmOh, those bags are cute! They’re made from lightweight material, too, right?
I’ve noticed that parents of babies are always lugging lots of stuff with them… might as well have cute accessories, LOL!
Tiffany says
February 9th, 2011 at 6:33 pmYah they are cotton so they weigh nothing and you can throw them in the washing machine. Seriously, I am gonna have tons of stuff to lug around!
Karen says
February 9th, 2011 at 7:07 pmThat’s smart to get one you can wash easily. I’ve admired the Kate Spade ones but know that the baby barf and poo are probably inevitable…
We have friends who visited a few months ago with a kid and man-oh-man, they were carting a LOT of stuff! I hope you’re doing your upper body workouts. 🙂
Nina says
February 9th, 2011 at 7:11 pmhello there Tabs! 🙂
ill probly pass on that powder 🙂
Karen says
February 10th, 2011 at 7:50 amTabs sends his regards, Nina! 🙂 He’s in his cat tower right now doing an impromptu grooming sesh.
Nina says
February 10th, 2011 at 8:02 amlast night, we took in stray gray (our name for the outdoor cat that graces us w/ his presence during mealtimes) because it was so cold. the three indoor kitties were not very happy. 😀
we set him out again this morning – hopefully he goes home (we think he has an owner/home) … 🙂
Lucie says
February 9th, 2011 at 7:20 pmIs MAC Prep and Prime really that great? I haven’t had any luck with translucent setting powders like Laura Mercier’s and MUFE’s-even with the lightest hand they end up looking chalky. I’m looking for something that controls oil but doesn’t give a completely matte finish…matte finishes make me look dead. 😀 Heading in to the ‘big city’ Saturday (and the only MAC store in vermont) to pick up some wonder woman collection goodies and am open to suggestions!
Karen says
February 10th, 2011 at 7:49 amHi Lucie,
I like it a lot. I use it when I’m out and about and for pictures and find it works really well for me. It keeps the oily spots in check, looks really natural on the skin and not too matte. I reviewed it a while back; here’s the link:
Say Hello to Glow with MAC Prep+Prime Transparent Finishing Powder
Another good one is MAC Blot:
MAC Blot Powder/Pressed: A Plot Against Oil and Shine!
Meghan says
February 9th, 2011 at 8:40 pmTabs is adorable! haha
Meghan recently posted … Clinique Milly Pretty in Prints
Karen says
February 10th, 2011 at 7:36 amHe likes to work the camera. 😉
Jen W says
February 9th, 2011 at 11:17 pmI’m surprised they call it ‘Photo Set’ when theres really no way of getting around that Zinc Oxide white cast thing…
I always go for non-sunscreen products when there’s bound to be flash photography.
Jen W recently posted … Ameli eye shadows- you rock my world! – Review and Swatches
Karen says
February 10th, 2011 at 7:33 amMe too. This one wasn’t too bad, but it might be a bigger issue for gals with darker skin tones.
Fieran says
February 10th, 2011 at 5:31 amAhh Karen, you are so selling the Prep+Prime Transparent Finishing powder to me 🙂 I’m definitely going to pick it up one of these days.
Fieran recently posted … Spring Lemmings
Karen says
February 10th, 2011 at 7:27 amIt’s a great little powder. If you do a 50/50 mix with Blot it looks great in photos and on camera!
Kajal Couture says
February 10th, 2011 at 5:57 amI like the Prep+Prime and I LOVE the Smashbox Halo powders, so if this is just good but not great…I will pass.
Kajal Couture recently posted … Costa Rica Cooldown- Korres Yoghurt Cooling Gel
Karen says
February 10th, 2011 at 7:25 amI remember trying the Halo powders a while back and liking them too…
Emma says
February 10th, 2011 at 12:16 pmKaren, I’m always worried about using these powders with my dry skin. Are the any that you’d recommend for dry skin or do you think it’s just better to stay away from them entirely?
So funny to see Tabs doing that pose. We thought it was a Maine Coon only pose. We call it Rooster’s slut pose and now Shadow copies Rooster – I think he caught on that it get’s him a tummy rub. Tabs looks so content!
Alka says
February 10th, 2011 at 12:44 pmI am so glad that I am not the only one who has a problem with seeing a whitish cast from these types of products! The staff at sephora swore up and down the MUFE HD powder was totally transparent. But on my nc40 it definitely is not. Still on the search for my HG setting powder…thanks for the great review!
Chris25 says
February 10th, 2011 at 5:17 pmI have been meaning to place a Smashbox order soon. I may buy this. I am also thinking of repurchasing Bionic Mascara in Indigo Ink. Should I try for a cheaper brand? I used to buy Maybelline Great Lash in Royal Blue, but I stopped because they test on animals.
Chris25 recently posted … The Goldmine- Urban Decay Baked
Alice says
February 11th, 2011 at 3:19 amOh, Tabs is lovely in this pic!!! I’m in love <3
Karen says
February 11th, 2011 at 7:44 amHe’s always posing for the camera, even when he’s sleeping. 😉
PS says
February 11th, 2011 at 6:32 pmi have this product & I love it! I like it better than the halo powder.
Molly says
February 12th, 2011 at 6:16 pmI use Make Up For Ever’s HD Microfinish, and like it pretty well, but I’ve never heard of zinc oxide being antimicrobial. That is cool! I learned something new today, which is good.
And, I just recharged my iPod Touch, so now I’ve got tunes again! Whew!