The Make Up For Ever Rock For Ever Eyeshadow Palette Rocked Me Like a Hurricane

Published in: Makeup, Product Reviews

karen from makeup and beauty blog reviews make up for ever rock for ever eye shadow palette

Oh, gawd! So I have another bad TV addiction, and they call it Dancing with the Stars. Why they call it that I’ll never know, since said “stars” include third string reality TV-ers like The Situation from MTV’s Jersey Shore and Audrina from The Hills, but I digress…



I was just channel surfing one night a few weeks ago when I randomly stopped to watch. I swear it was like when Britney had her breakdown and shaved her head. I desperately wanted to look away but couldn’t. The show had me by the eyeballs and would not let go!

Maybe it was the sparkly costumes or the pyrotechnic displays (seriously, on stage fire is like the oldest trick in the “you gotta watch this!” book), but now I’m hooked. And who knew that Jennifer Grey would still be such a kick @ss dancer after all these years, or that 6’8″ Rick Fox would have to work on pointing his toes?

Last night’s episode had a rock n’ roll theme, which means flames, a weird appearance by Bret Michels and his blonder than blond weave, and an awkward pasodoble danced by former NFL champ Kurt Warner (El Hub is totally rooting for him!).

None of it really rocked and rolled to me, but the Make Up For Ever Rock For Ever Eye Palette ($45), on the other hand — that’s another story. Now THAT to me is ROCK. N. FRICKIN’. ROLL!

make up for ever rock for ever eye shadow palette review small product photo picture

This limited edition studded eyeshadow palette from the Rock For Ever Holiday 2010 Collection could probably pass for jewelry, yet it’s so much more! It comes with four shadows designed for sultry, sexy smokey eyes.

The soft, pigmented shadows blend together seamlessly and remind me of the Stila shadows in the Backstage Eye Palette in how fluffy they are. I think these, however, perform better. They aren’t as apt to migrate, last throughout the day and don’t look as heavy on the lids.

  • 307: Make Up For Ever didn’t skimp on the glitter in this smokey black shadow. It’s filled to the brim! And they didn’t hold back on pigment, either — a welcome change after all of the sheer glittery shadows that’ve popped up over the last year from Urban Decay and Bobbi Brown. Yet despite the glitter and pigment, there’s very little fallout with this; it’s absolutely my favorite color in the quad.
  • 306: Including this shimmery peachy tan was a smart move because I think it brings some warmth to the quad that was lacking among many of the smokey eye palettes out there now. Wear it in the crease to enhance contrast and depth.
  • 82: I think my skin brings out the blue tones in silver shades, so this shimmery silver/gray may not look as blue on lighter lovelies.
  • 07: Wearing this shimmery white at the inner corners of the eyes is like a double shot of espresso (makes me look wide awake)!

Oh! A couple of you ladies wondered if Rock For Ever could be a possible dupe for the MAC Leopard Luxe palette from Fabulous Felines, so I took a closer look.

The peachy shades in both could definitely pass for cousins, but I think the one in Rock For Ever looks peachier than the more golden Leopard Luxe. Beyond that, though, I think the rest of the shades stand on their own, and the ones in Leopard Luxe seem warmer to me, with a lot of brown, than Rock For Ever’s cooler colors (with the exception of 306).

make up for ever rock for ever eye shadow palette review comparison-to-leopard-luxe
MAC Leopard Luxe Quad (left) and Rock For Ever (right)

make up for ever rock for ever eye shadow palette review swatches-2
MAC Leopard Luxe swatches

make up for ever rock for ever eye shadow palette review swatches 1
Rock For Ever Swatches from left: 307, 306, 82, 07

make up for ever rock for ever eye shadow palette review eye

karen from makeup and beauty blog reviews make up for ever rock for ever eye shadow palette

With Rock For Ever, I think you get a beautiful smokey eye palette with some of the most cooperative shadows I’ve seen in a long time (easy to blend, long lasting). The $45 price roughly breaks down to $11 per 0.08-oz. pan (which compares favorably to a 0.05-oz. MAC shadow single for $14.50). And here you get the studly (ha ha) limited packaging, too!

Can you tell I’m in love love?

A few products mentioned in this post…

PRICE: $45
AVAILABILITY: At Sephora stores and online
MAKEUP AND BEAUTY BLOG RATING: A+

Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,

Karen

62 Comments

Like this post? Tell your friends!

So far, 62 people have commented on this article. How cool is that?

  1. Phyrra says:

    That’s a beautiful look on you! It definitely looks like it’s got good pigmentation in that palette, too.
    Phyrra recently posted … Shiro Twilight Midna

  2. steph b says:

    This gives you a similar look to one you did recently where you warmed up a smoky, silver eye. I immediately gave that a shot and love it. This palette looks like the pans are removable — are they? That is one of my pet peeves about the MAC palettes. It would be such a great bonus to get a reusable palette or be able to swap out one of the shades if it wasn’t quite what you wanted.

    • Karen says:

      Oh yah, that was the Dior one. So glad to hear that the mix of warm/cool shades worked for you!

      As for the pans, yes, they’re removable. It’s totally easy to do, too.

      • steph b says:

        Yep, the Dior was what I was thinking of.

        Love that you can swap pans. Think I’ll check this out when I’m at the mall later this week.

        I was sucked into DWTS last night too. Was sorta like having to watch a high speed car chase until it ended. Some of the stars just looked so stiff. And I remember watching Rick Fox play ball when he was at Carolina and we always made fun of his big butt so it was awesome to see him make fun of boxing people out with it.

  3. Nina says:

    i was eyeballing that … maybe i should cave in and lift the eyeshadow ban. its soooo pretty! :)

  4. Gina says:

    I have the 307 shade in a single, and it’s such an amazing black! I recognized it right away when I saw that bucket o’ silver glitter staring back at me on the screen. It really does make for a lovely smokey eye.

  5. knownever says:

    that packaging looks really cool. Is that a little drawer that slides out with the second set of shadows?
    knownever recently posted … DIYBacktoMAC

  6. Etsy Breslin says:

    Gorgeous look! I wish I could be makeup shopping right now..it’s Tuesday and I’m already counting down the hours until the weekend :(

  7. Evelyn says:

    Hmm, I was thinking of getting the MAC Twists of Tartan palette, but maybe I’ll scrounge up 9 more bucks and get this one instead. Thanks for the review!

  8. Amber says:

    I’m skipping this, but you definitely look ready to rock!
    Amber recently posted … Balsamic beef stew

  9. MG says:

    how funny, i’ve been lemming 306 es for awhile!!

    BTW – what lg are you wearing? LOVE it!!

  10. Tiffany H. says:

    OMG! So gorgeous! And you totally rocked it!
    Tiffany H. recently posted … Manicure Mondays-Orly Mirror Mirror

  11. no other words but you are GORGEOUS! not just the makeup and MUFE but your hair too!
    jojoba (My Makeup Reviews) recently posted … Review: Cancer Council Australia Lipstick SPF30

  12. Nikki says:

    Karen!! Love the look! I’m dying to know what lipcolor you have on in this pic. It’s absolutely gorgeous and I must have it!! Lol!!!

  13. ooh this really is a lovely smokey eye palette, I love that they threw that peach in there too. It balances the cool colors nicely, and yay for nonfail, glittery, black eyeshadows. :)
    makeup morsels recently posted … Miscellaneous Monday Morsels 10/25/10

  14. Michelle says:

    That looks gorgeous on you!! And I am with you on DWTS. I love it! Although it doesn’t bring out the best in me — I find myself criticizing people like The Situation who name their abs or people who have had way too much plastic surgery. But hellur, it some good TV viewing lol

    • Karen says:

      It’s pretty darn amusing. Did you see the episode where Mrs. Brady did that naughty dance where she was all shaking her money maker? Oh my heavens… NOT APPROPRIATE!

  15. snoopysteph says:

    I love it! The glittery black shade is awesome!

  16. Carolina says:

    Wow, your skin looks so flawless!!! What foundation are you wearing??

  17. Jen says:

    I had talked myself out of this palette, but I think this review just talked me back into putting it on the top of my holiday wish list… Sigh.

    You look great!

  18. Alison S says:

    ohh I love the cover of the palette. And I love that it has a mirror inside so you can take it on the go. That smokey eye looks really good on you! how did you do your hair? I love the curls!

    • Karen says:

      Hi Alison,

      I wish I could say there was a method to the madness, but I honestly just let my hair go nuts. I washed it the night before, and then went to bed with it a kinda damp and let it air dry over night. The next day I had it in a loose ponytail for an hour or so, then I spritzed it with some water and put in some Got2B Fatastic Mousse that I’m testing out. And that craziness is what I ended up with, LOL!

  19. inaya says:

    what lipgloss are you wearing Karen? simply stunning shade on you

  20. Nika says:

    Wow I can totally see what you’re talking about. Those colors really make your eyes pop! They look beautiful on you! Maybe I can convince my parents to buy this for me since I can’t exactly afford it with a student’s allowance. :D

  21. mela says:

    karen this palette is gorgeous on you! thanks for the stellar review, as always ;)

    also i just found out that MUFE pro members can use their discount at the boutiques inside the sephora in soho which is great for those little sephora-only products like this palette and the rock liner set

    xoxo
    mela recently posted … 4 days leftdo not pass go without collecting urban decays liners

  22. pia says:

    Karen, you rocked this look! I just wondered if the black shadow is similar to the black/silver duo from L’oreal. I have that and use it perhaps 3 times (or less) since I bought it a couple of years ago.

    And yeah, I envy your lips :D

    • Karen says:

      Hi Pia,

      Hmm… I’m not sure if I’m familiar with that shade. If your shadow is 1) very pigmented and 2) very glittery (but with fine glitter, not chunky), then it sounds like the MUFE color could be a possible dupe.

  23. justjillian says:

    oooh, this is a fantastic quad!!! looks fab on you!

  24. Kim says:

    I’m definitely with you on the packaging, but colors that equal sultry, sexy smokey eyes on you translate to terrifying, homeless raccoon on me. :)

    I haven’t seen this season of DWTS but have watched a couple in the past and, like El Hub, I’m always cheering for the football players (Jerry Rice rocks!). And speaking of Brett Michaels, if it’s wrong to still love Talk Dirty to Me, I don’t want to be right. :)

  25. lexi says:

    This quad looks like a perfect introduction for me to MUFE shadows. I might just get #307 on it’s own since you speak so highly about it!

  26. Bella says:

    I love your blog and reviews!! What are you wearing on your lips and cheeks? Thanks!

  27. Lauren says:

    So happy to hear the black shade doesn’t have fall out, this one’s definitely going on the wish list! :)
    Lauren recently posted … Maybelline Moisture Extreme Lipstick ‘Born with It’

  28. Instant Karma (formerly L) says:

    Oooh, looks pretty! I especially like the peachy color.

    LOL, DWTS is my guilty pleasure, too! I started watching it last season because Evan Lysacek was on it, and I figured I’d check it out this season because I was pretty amused by it. I kind of love Tom Bergeron’s sarcastic comments about, well, everything, lol. I have to say that I’m rooting for Brandy to take the whole thing, although Jennifer is clearly still a great dancer as well. Rick Fox is super adorable when he dances, and also has aged SPECTACULARLY. Good God, he’s handsome. Also, wow, yeah, Bret Michaels was weird, but I had to laugh when he was all “ANNA, YOU’RE THE BEST…IN CLEVELAND.”

  29. Yay! I was hoping for this–good pigmentation, easily blendable, etc. I love the cute packaging and it looks fab on you! I think this would make a really nice gift too!
    Cindy (Prime Beauty) recently posted … Chanel Limited Edition Holiday GiftsDeserve a Spot On Your X-mas List!

  30. Tasha says:

    hey doesn’t this look scarily like one of The Body Shop’s new eye palettes from the Winter Trend 2010 line?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge

css.php