Paul & Joe Waterproof Gel Eye Liner: Water Doesn’t Bother This Kitty Cat

Published in: Eyes, Makeup, Paul & Joe, Product Reviews

paul & joe waterproof gel eye liner

NOTE TO SELF: Next time Tabs insists on going for an impromptu walk in the rain (believe it or not, this has actually happened), grab Paul & Joe’s Waterproof Gel Eye Liner in Black ($25), because once this quick-drying matte black gel sets on my lash lines, it won’t even flinch in a downpour.

Part of the new eight-piece limited edition Kitten Collection, Gel Eye Liner feels thick, dense and kind of reminds me of a drier, grayer version of MAC Fluidline in Blacktrack.

I don’t think it clings to water lines anywhere near as well, but on rainy, rushed days when all I want are quick cat eyes, Gel Eye Liner delivers. It dries in just about a minute, and after that, I get a good 12 hours out of it without any smudging or fading.

For more on the Paul & Joe Kitten Collection, check out…

The liner also comes with a flat, tapered retractable brush that performs surprisingly well and draws thick and thin lines with ease. Using it to apply Gel Eye Liner creates lines that look a little bit blurred at the edges, for an effect that’s more soft than precise.

If you’re looking for lines with a crisper edge, you might want to apply this with something like the Sonia Kashuk Bent Eyeliner Brush instead.

paul & joe kitten collection waterproof gel eye liner black cat cool
Waterproof Gel Eye Liner in Black (sometimes called Black Cat Cool)

paul & joe kitten collection waterproof gel eye liner black cat cool
Waterproof Gel Eye Liner in Black (sometimes called Black Cat Cool)

paul & joe waterproof gel eye liner

Color my cat eyes impressed with Paul & Joe Waterproof Gel Eye Liner. I wish it performed better along the water line, but depending on how you intend to wear it, that might not be an issue at all.

PRICE: $25
AVAILABILITY: Available now at Paul & Joe counters and also online

I love you
Whether you’re in a relationship now or flying solo (been there many times myself), I hope you had a reason to celebrate love today (not just romantic love, but all kinds of love). If I had my way, we’d celebrate love every day of the year.

Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,



For more on Paul & Joe’s Kitten Collection and Collection Sparkles, check out…


Like this post? Tell your friends!

Promoted Content

So far, 30 people have commented on this article. How cool is that?

  1. Chris25 says:

    This eyeliner looks awesome. I love gel liners.

    Jazz is thrilled to be back home. The girls are happy to have their brother back, and I’m just glad my little boy was saved. :) He’s doing fine, but his bladder stretched while he was blocked, so he tends to leak urine now. I also have to give him wet food from now on, and the doctor told me about Hills Prescription food, which is supposedly a better kind.

  2. Adrienne says:

    Retractable eyeliner brush. Dear god, WHY have I never seen one before, that’s genius!!

    Where is Paul and Joe sold? I’ve neve seen it around, but I absolutely love them for this collection!!!

    • Karen says:

      I know! The only thing is you have to clean it every time you use it, otherwise it starts getting all crusty and gross.

      I get Paul & Joe online. The only other place I’ve seen it in person is the DFS Galleria on Oahu.

  3. corallista says:

    I like thick liner on you. Something looks different today, is it a new concealer?
    corallista recently posted … Make Up For Ever Rouge Artist Intense Mat 4 Lipstick : Review, Swatch and FOTD

    • Karen says:

      I used a little MAC Mineralize Concealer on the inner corners. I also used less foundation and powder, which I think allowed more sheen from MAC Strobe cream to come through. Thanks for noticing! :)

  4. I swear by the gel liners in the humidity of Florida but I’d never heard of this brand before. I will have to keep an eye out & when its time to replenish, give them a shot. Thanks for letting me know about them.
    Kellie ~ The Shoe Diva recently posted … Flirty and fun shoes, up to 70% off ~ After Valentines Day sale

    • Karen says:

      They’re a boutique line that used to be carried at Sephora about six years ago; now they’re harder to find. They have some nice items, especially the powders!

  5. Erin says:

    I spent the day with my cat Toffee, unfortunately he couldn’t afford to take me out for a meal but he tried his best to make it up to mel- brought three mice in for me during the night! Clearly a sign of devotion! The eyeliner looks gorgeous, especially with the lip colour! x

  6. Love you too Karen!

    This liner looks super black and opaque! I’m a big fan of gel liners myself :)

  7. Nina says:

    i <3 you too, Karen! and pls tell Tabs i <3 him as well!

    the liner is gorgeous … why must you add to my growing longer and longer p&j shopping list???

  8. This is pricier than my trusty Blacktrack Fluidline, but I sure do like the lid of the jar and that it comes with a brush!

  9. Kim says:

    Lots of love coming back at you, Karen! :)

    The liner looks really nice and I never wear any on my waterlines so that wouldn’t be an issue. I’m sort of getting into softer, smudged looks lately, though. I think the bold lines are starting to look too harsh on this old mug! :)

    • Karen says:

      Thanks, Kim. :) Can’t ever have enough of it!

      Old mug? No way, I don’t believe it! Although I do love me a really soft line… that way when things start getting smudgy it looks purposeful.

      How’s your week going so far? Mine has been busy. IS IT FRIDAY YET?

      • Kim says:

        Oh, I wish! One more day! Then again, the Hubs is out of town and the boys have a hockey tourney starting tomorrow evening, so I’ll probably be busier on the weekend than I have been this week! :)

        You’ll see how spastic I am when you read my major over-reaction in the Adele comments. HAHA! I’m such a dodo sometimes! :)

        How are things shaping up for your weekend? Any fun plans?

  10. Staci says:

    Does the retractable brush compare to the one from Sonia K.? Also, in addition to my beloved fluidlines I’ve fallen for the Essence gel liners…how does this compare?

    • Karen says:

      Hi Staci,

      They’re both good for different reasons. I find that with Sonia’s bent brush, I can get a sharper, cleaner edge. With this brush, the lines are softer and more diffused.

      Re: Essence… aren’t those liner great? So cheap, too. Paul & Joe’s is drier and slightly thicker. I also think it’s sturdier. If you want real deal waterproof, then P&J might be the way to go.

      Let me know if you have any other questions!

      • Staci says:

        Thanks for the reply Karen. I do have the bent liner brush (on you recommendation and I love it-I also have ELF’s studio brand one that I travel with) but I was referring to the retractable liner brush from Sonia. The silver one, have you seen it?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge