Is Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor, Well, Pretty Amazing?

Published in: Makeup, Product Reviews

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor strength 1

When makeup marketers name a product “Pretty Amazing,” they’re setting the bar high. I mean, what do they do if the product only ends up being mediocre? How do they answer their boss when she asks, “How did those new Pretty Amazing Lipcolors turn out?” Well, miss, I think they turned out…fine.

Ouch.

I have to admit, I had high expectations when I heard about the new Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolors line of hybrid liquid lipgloss/lipsticks ($16 each). I wondered if they’d make my eyes roll back in my head in ecstasy (I hope!). Would I find myself speaking in tongues?

Judging by their names, the eight new Lipcolors do have a certain swagger. There’s Bravado (a brick rose), Charisma (a coral pink), Ambition (a fuchsia), Courage (a warm strawberry), Fearless (a rosy mauve), Free Will (a pink nude; oddly, I keep wanting to call this one “Free Willy”), Moxie (a bright petal pink) and Strength (a vibrant red). Hot. I’ll call your positive messages, Bare Minerals, and raise you some power. :)

No, these aren’t lipglosses for wallflowers. They’re much stronger than that. These are like lipglosses on P90X — super thick and sticky with full-color coverage and subtle shine. Imagine the thick, sticky texture of a MAC Lipglass coupled with the uber-pigmented power of the NYX Soft Matte Lip Creams and BAM! — you’re Pretty Amazing.

They’re also unscented and unflavored, but neither of those is their most amazing trait. That distinction goes to their color. It’s saturated and opaque, like the stuff of technicolor dreams.

Even though I find some of the brighter, bolder shades like Strength a little tricky to apply, the flocked applicator helps. As long as I use it with a slow, steady hand, I’m able to precisely draw crisp lines along the edges of my lips.

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor iphone
Beside an iPhone for scale…

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor wands

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor swatches flash
Swatches from left with the flash: Bravado, Charisma, Ambition, Courage, Fearless, Free Will, Moxie and Strength

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor swatches without
Swatches without the flash

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor courage swatch
Courage

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor free will swatch
Free Will

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor fearless swatch
Fearless

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor charisma swatch
Charisma

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor moxie swatch
Moxie

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor bravado swatch
Bravado

Bare Minerals Pretty Amazing Lipcolor ambition swatch
Ambition

Speaking of Ambition, Bare Minerals showed some with these, but would I call them amazing? Maybe. I was hoping they’d feel more moisturizing and would last a little longer on my lips. I get about four hours with them, which is good for a long-wearing lip product, but is it amazing? :)

I think their texture and finish also leave some room for improvement. Bare Minerals calls it a high-shine finish, but I have to respectfully disagree. As far as shine, I find myself wanting more. I also feel like my lips look older and drier wearing Pretty Amazing, as the product eventually settles into my larger vertical lines.

I love, LOVE these rich colors, and I really dig their names (Fearless? That’s great!), but calling them Pretty Amazing just might have been a stretch.

PRICE: $16 each
AVAILABILITY: Available in May at Bare Escentuals Boutiques and also online
MAKEUP AND BEAUTY BLOG RATING: B+

Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,

Karen

P.S. Goodness, what happened to Tuesday? It’s like I opened my eyes this morning, answered some emails and now it’s 8:30 at night. I can’t believe it. Well, I guess it means we’re one step closer to Friday.

96 Comments

Like this post? Tell your friends!

So far, 96 people have commented on this article. How cool is that?

  1. LOVE courage, fearless, & ambition! those are the shades i tend to gravitate towards.

    i’m a little concerned about the thickness, though. it looks like it would be pretty gloopy and i’m kind of fussy about textures.

    also, strength looks super, SUPER gorgeous on you!
    dani@callitbeauty recently posted … Collection Spotlight- Giambattista Valli – Spring 2011

  2. Vijaya says:

    Well, they said “Pretty Amazing” not “ZOMFG, This Is Seriously Amazing”. I do like the looks of a couple of these. I love your lip swatches!
    Vijaya recently posted … Linnaeus Cosmetics Review- The Overview Details and Things

  3. Tracy says:

    I’m loving Ambition! And Moxie! And Courage! You look great in ALL of them!
    Tracy recently posted … LashControl Mascara Is Genius In a Tube!

  4. Siena says:

    beautiful colors, although I’m a little worried about the cons that come with these :/

  5. Molly SC says:

    I might just have to snatch up Bravado- that is SUCH a great color!

  6. Sarah says:

    Karen,
    Those lipcolors look so fab! I’m around the same color as you so I’m hoping I look even half as good in them as you do! By the way, what blush are you wearing? It also looks gorg!

  7. AnieJ says:

    From the swatches, I was going to say that Charisma was my favorite, but seeing that picture of you with Courage on….whoo dang girl! You just blew my mind! I think I’ll be picking Courage up for a night on the town…just me and the lipcolor, mind you, you gotta romance it a bit.
    AnieJ recently posted … Bobbi Brown Award Winning Face Touch-Up Stick in Warm Ivory 1

  8. Valbona Prokshi says:

    Very pigmented and cute!

  9. Appu says:

    They seem mighty pigmented! My fav. is Courage :)
    Appu recently posted … Stila Convertible Color in Lillium

  10. Jessi says:

    I think calling them Pretty Amazing is just setting themselves up for disappointment. They should have been named “Pretty Mediocre” so that when people tried them they would be astonished at how much better than mediocre they really are. i have to say they do look all kinds of gorgeous on you, though.
    Jessi recently posted … Random NOTD- Hidden Treasure over OPIs Im His Coral Friend Matte

  11. shontay says:

    You look gorgeous, Karen. Seriously, all of these work on you. Now I am interested. I just hope these don’t cause a reaction with me b/c I definitely cannot wear their foundations. I’m willing to find out, though. :)

    • Karen says:

      Hi Shontay,

      You and I are in the same boat. I tried the foundation years ago and broke out like CRAZY. The lip and eye products seem to not irritate my skin though…

  12. Ashley says:

    Karen are you wearing “Strength” in the main photo?

  13. Jan says:

    These look similar to Chanel Rouge Allure Laque.

  14. Jen says:

    Ah, I love this! I have yet to try the NYX cream ones but I imagine these are wonderful! ^_^
    Jen recently posted … Two week cleansing cycle DONE!

  15. Charisse says:

    Courage looks amazing…but WOW these are super pigmented! IM IN LOVE!

  16. claudia says:

    courage looks super pretty on you!

  17. elisabeth says:

    Do you remember MAC Lip Varnish in Autobody Red? That’s what the red one reminds me of…

  18. gio says:

    They look so pretty and pigmented! Love courage!
    gio recently posted … Is Mineral Makeup Drying

  19. Jen W says:

    Love the look of Bravado and Courage.

    It’s a shame that they’re not ‘pretty amazing’ though in terms of the texture. I loathe lippies that settle into lip lines
    Jen W recently posted … Bobbi Brown Lip Balm SPF 15- a review

  20. Bellyrockin says:

    They remind me very much of MAC’s Kissable Lip Colours

  21. a!kO says:

    Wow, I am loving the colors of these :D Especially Bravado.

    x0x0
    a!kO recently posted … Wishlist- I want that!

  22. Wendy says:

    Courage was the only swatch that looked like something I might try. Then I saw it on you. The color looks amazing on you. I’m going to have to pass on it due to the thick, goopey, heavy textured look. Too much of a good thing just like P90X. It was more like P110X for me. Towards the end, I just couldn’t stomach the same workout.

    • Karen says:

      I have a friend who does P90X; he told me it’s pretty hard core. I dunno… I don’t think I’m ready for that jelly, LOL! I’ll stick to running.

  23. Karen says:

    I looovvveee how courage looks on you!!!!

  24. kalcedon says:

    I pretty much like Courage :).

  25. shiny says:

    Rhetorical question: Why is ‘Ambition’ fuschia? :)

  26. Kim says:

    Bravado and Courage look great on you! The swatches remind me of brightly colored latex, though, especially in the flash photos. :) I wasn’t impressed with Bare Minerals foundation (and one of their brushes came unglued the 2nd time I used it), so I am definitely biased against the brand. I should probably let that go!

    • Karen says:

      I know what you mean. I tried their powder foundation years ago and broke out, too. They were painful pimples — you know, the ones that feel like they’ve got roots? I’m slowly getting to know the line and I like some of their color stuff. They definitely seem to have a cult following!

      • Kim says:

        I’ll try to check out some of their color stuff; after all, even makeup lines need a second chance sometimes! :)

        • Karen says:

          I’m still very nervous about the face products, but I think venturing into color’s pretty safe. A lot of people seem to really love the line. You never know…

  27. Nicky Bromow says:

    Bravado is, to me, the one that suits you best, It makes your skin pop and look gorgeous!

  28. jillian m. says:

    in spite of the cons, these look amazing on you (especially courage)! rich, vibrant colors–i love it!
    jillian m. recently posted … things i learned from michael pollan

  29. Jade says:

    I love ‘em! All of ‘em! But I think courage and charisma might be my favorites.

  30. Nina says:

    unscented and unflavored? count me in! im loving ambition, strength courage and m moxie! :)

  31. Tracy Hathaway says:

    Are these comparable to the Chanel Rouge Allure Laques?

  32. Tukta says:

    Is it similar to Chanel??? I don’t remember the name of Chanel products but they have this kind of lip that not gloss, not lipstick

  33. Amista says:

    I LOVE Courage! Very beautiful!
    Amista recently posted … LUSH NEW! Solid Shampoo

  34. JoElla says:

    I have one of these from a TSV from QVC, and I like the color, but found them to be quite sticky and gloppy. It felt sticky on my lips and almost hard to control the application.

    What worked for me was blotting the heck out of it, and throwing a bit of gloss over it. They are long wearing, but I am just not a fan of gummy lip sticks.

  35. Trisha says:

    Bravado looks great on you! It totally goes with your shirt.
    Trisha recently posted … Giveaway- Lumixyl Topical Brightening System

  36. Basak says:

    Well, my favorite is Bravado on you Karen!

  37. Barb says:

    They all look great on you but I think I like Fearless the best for me. I saw these on QVC but resisted ordering them then ( I hate having to pay shipping unless I’m getting an awesome deal). I’ll definitely have to check them out.

    I used BE foundation for years but recently converted to Tarte Amazonian Clay Foundation. I got a TSV kit of Tarte makeup from QVC and love it!

  38. Solangel says:

    I’m sure these are so not good for kissing :P
    Solangel recently posted … Grandpas things- Rose bundt pan

  39. Rachel says:

    OMG Karen! I think these look super on your lips! I want to try them out but still have trouble finding a pretty lipgloss because I’m so pale. What would your suggestions be?

    • Karen says:

      Hi Rachel,

      It depends on what look you’re going for. I personally love the contrast of bold lips against pale skin, so I think you could do any of these colors…

  40. nia says:

    bravado & courage looks awesome on you~

    i wonder how does these fare to illamasqua’s intense lipglosses?

  41. Moni says:

    I *need* Courage!

    Do you have a picture of your bare lips? I’m trying to figure out if our colouring is similar!

    • Karen says:

      Hi Moni,

      Unfortch I don’t think I do. Mine are pretty pigmented though… Do you ever wear MAC Subculture Lip Pencil? That’s like the same color are my lips.

  42. Instant Karma (formerly L) says:

    Aw, that’s a shame. Strength looks GORGEOUS. Then again, I really don’t need another vibrant red lip gloss, considering I already own approximately eight million of them…

  43. Anh says:

    I have a Bare Escentuals gift card with nothing that interested me at BE until these glosses. Thanks for the post and swatches Karen!
    Anh recently posted … masquerade masks

  44. Rhapsode says:

    I suppose saying “pretty amazing” is akin to saying “virtually guaranteed”–weasel words, them.
    Rhapsode recently posted … Help Mother Earth Live Long And Prosper- Zoyas Earth Day Promo!

  45. Lisa B. says:

    Nuts, I was hoping they’d be nonsticky as well…as a few people already said, it looks a lot like those Rouge Allure Laques…

  46. Amanda says:

    The glosses look great on you. I was actually wondering what blush and eye shadows you had on in these pictures. They look natural and fresh, I love them.

  47. karen says:

    do you find strength to be more warm-toned or cool-toned?

  48. Megan says:

    Hi Karen
    Long time follower/lurker/non poster!
    I have to politely disagree with the comment of these being sticky. in Australia these are fairly new and maybe, just maybebthey have a different formula here? these definitely feel thick but creamy like a cream liquid lipstick. they feel smooth to me, in no way sticky!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge

css.php