I’m Feeling Neutral About the Anastasia All Eye Want Palette

Published in: Makeup, Product Reviews

Anastasia All Eye Want Palette (4)

When Urban Decay coaxed thousands of us (maybe millions!) into getting Naked last year, it prompted many of the big makeup lines to follow suit with neutral palettes of their own. And just like that! — neutral was the new black. 🙂


I’m not complaining, of course. I’m always down to play with easy-to-wear colors. Colors like the cocoas, caramels and latte shades in the new limited edition Anastasia All Eye Want Palette ($32, exclusive to Sephora).

Anastasia All Eye Want Palette (3)

The palette, which Anastasia created with weekend getaways (and very likely coffee-based drinks, LOL!) in mind, contains nine neutral shadows, some shimmery and some matte, and small versions of her Clear Brow Gel and Lash Lifting Mascara.

Anastasia All Eye Want Palette (1)

Anastasia All Eye Want Palette (2)

Anastasia All Eye Want Palette (5)

I think Anastasia picked a great selection of colors here — shades neither too warm nor too cool — which should be very accessible to a wide range of skin tones.

On performance, though, the shadows vary dramatically, with the buttery, easy-to-blend mattes hitting all the right notes for casual weekend looks.

I think the shimmers and glitters, on the other hand, leave room for refinement. Like the mattes, they boast medium pigmentation, but they sure take after Orville and Wilbur Wright…meaning that they like to fly around. 🙂

Definitely keep your makeup wipes handy for cleanup when you bust these out.

As for other pieces, the Brow Gel and mascara, both of them deliver. Sasquatch brows better fear the Brow Gel, which is clearly one of Anastasia’s specialties, and the mascara, while not for dramatic lashes, has natural lash looks down pat.

All in all, an okay kit with a nice selection of colors, some top-tier matte shadows and a fantastic brow gel. If Anastasia could refine the shimmers in a future version of the kit, I think she’d have a home run.

The All Eye Want Palette is one of four holiday 2011 gift sets from Anastasia…

  • Bright Eyes, Big City ($39; available at Nordstrom)
  • Kisses on My List ($30; available at Sephora)
  • All Eye Want Palette ($32; available at Sephora)
  • Skin Essentials ($70; available at Nordstrom)

PRICE: $32
AVAILABILITY: Available now exclusively at Sephora stores and also online

Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,



P.S. Doesn’t it seem like the days get shorter around this time of year? I mean not just sunlight hours, but overall? I feel like the weeks are moving at 2x speed!

It’s almost Thanksgiving, a perfect time for a recipe exchange. 🙂

We did one last year, and I got some great dishes to try. Who’s game to hold another one this year?

Thanksgiving… Just writing the word makes me hungry, LOL!


Like this post? Tell your friends!

So far, 7 people have commented on this article. How cool is that?

  1. Shadiah says:

    I looove this look! I wish I knew how to do it. It looks so natural but not boring. It also gives you a well-rested look!

  2. Chris25 says:

    The colors are really pretty!

    This year, I’m making my famous sour cream apple pie for the boyfriend’s birthday.


  3. Katy says:

    For Thanksgiving my man is making a side dish of mac n cheese with Gouda, bacon, sausage, and sauteed onions… I feel my a$$ expanding as I type haha 🙂 The palette is pretty but really can anybody beat the naked palette???

  4. You look great in those colors, but from just looking at the palette alone nothing jumps out at me. I’m still waiting for Bobbi Brown to bring back her Chocolate Palette—amazeballs! That was the perfect neutral palette..oh well..the search for an alternate continues!
    a beauty loft recently posted … New Exclusive at Target: Boob Lift In a Tube?

  5. I like the look of all the shades in this palette – very versatile:) How do you feel about a family recipe called “Caterpillar Salad”? I can’t have Thanksgiving without it!
    The Blossom Shed Beauty Blog recently posted … Lazy Links

  6. Vonvon says:

    Nice palette but I think the NYX one with similar 9 eyeshadows has better pigmentation, etc, compared to this one.
    Vonvon recently posted … Let’s Celebrate 11.11.11 With The Festival Eyeshadow Palette From Famous By Sue Moxley! Review & Swatches

  7. Nina says:

    i love the look you did w/ the palette but it just seems so … meh to me. i saw it last night at sephora and i wasnt wowed. 🙂

    i am so game for the recipe exchange!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge