Diorshow Iconic Mascara Lengthens, Curls and Defines Lashes with Ease

Tue, 09/2/2008 by Karen | Posted in: Makeup, Product Reviews

Some products are so good in certain ways that their strengths totally outweigh their weaknesses. For me, Diorshow Iconic Mascara ($27) is one of those products.

The newest member of Dior’s lash arsenal doesn’t produce the thickest lashes I’ve ever seen. It doesn’t thicken as well as, say, Chanel Exceptionnel does, but it lengthens, curls and defines lashes so amazingly well that I don’t mind at all.

It’s even easy to apply, never clumping or flaking. Together, its strengths make Iconic one of the overall best mascaras I’ve tried in years.

With its long, skinny teeth, the plastic comb brush morphs my lashes into a natural-looking feathered fringe. The brush grabs even the smallest and stubbiest individual lashes, thoroughly coating and defining each one with mascara. The result is long, dark lashes of equal length.

This is what two coats of Iconic looks like. I think it’s a natural lash look (yet still a little sexy) with added oomph. This stuff is totally like the hot girl-next-door of mascaras.

The formula holds the curl from my Shu Uemura curler all day long and doesn’t smudge, not even after hours of wear.

Diorshow Iconic Mascara in Noir

Price: $27
Use: To lengthen, curl and define lashes
Makeup and Beauty Blog Rating: A

I like Iconic as a daytime mascara and have been wearing it to work and on the weekends. If you’re single and dating, I can see you wearing it on lunch dates, or perhaps to the Japanese Tea Garden for afternoon tea. Your date wouldn’t be able to take his eyes off your sexy, bedroom lashes!

At $27, Diorshow Iconic isn’t drugstore cheap, but the fact that I can wear it every day makes it feel like a pretty good value.

If you’re looking for a high-end mascara with solid overall performance, then Diorshow Iconic might be just the thing. :)

Your friendly neighborhood beauty addict,

Karen

Bookmark and Share Share this Entry | 49 Comments

« Miss Oops Mishap Tape Prevents Wardrobe Mishaps | September Retro Roundup: One Year Ago on Makeup and Beauty Blog »

So far, 49 people have commented on this post. How cool is that?

  1. 1. Jaime said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    HOT!

    Jaimes last blog post..Great Stila Deals at beautycrunch.com

  2. 2. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Jaime,

    Thanks. Are you a Diorshow fan?

  3. 3. katy said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    I love the japanese tea garden. It’s so fun. And the almond cookies they serve are to DIE for. (Plus you can buy Hello Panda snacks there, which are my fave!)

    But I also adore paddle boating at Golden Gate Park, too!

    I like Dior Show mascara, but it smudges too easily and weighs down the curl in my lashes. It’s nice to see this one doesn’t, although my blonde eyelashes need a lot of pumping up! Maybe I’ll check it out next time I’m in Sephora.

  4. 4. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Katy,

    Me too! It’s one of the gems in the park. :)

    I used Diorshow back in the day, and while I liked it I wanted to try other brands. If you stick to one or two coats of Iconic you probably won’t have an issue with it weighing down your lashes!

    So far, the mascaras that I like best for plumping are Chanel Exceptionnel, MAC Plush Lash and MAC Zoomlash.

  5. 5. Anna said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Karen,

    I’m not a fan of Dior mascara’s I think they are over rated and does nothing for lashes. I prefer YSL False Lash effect, which give amazing skyscraper lashes to die for.

  6. 6. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Anna,

    I’ve heard great things about YSL. I haven’t gotten around to trying their mascaras yet, but will hopefully soon!

  7. 7. Tiera said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    I’m itching to try Iconic!

    Tieras last blog post..The Month Ahead: September

  8. 8. Brenda said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    I’m glad someone finally reviewed this because descriptions always say they do everything and I highly doubted that this one would have given me length and volume but since there is such a good rating on curling and lengthening I think I shall buy this (as well as Chanel).

  9. 9. lindsay said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Your lashes look great, but the brush reminds me of Cover Girl’s lash exact (i think?) the one in the green tube and I didn’t really like that one. I’ve always wanted to try Shu’s mascara basic, but I’m scared I’ll fall in love with it because it’s so expensive! Have you ever tried it?

  10. 10. Marisol said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    How would you compare this to the other two Dior mascaras? I am a die hard fan of DiorShow. Whenever I have a bit of extra cash,I will get that mascara.

    Marisols last blog post..America, this is one of those moments.

  11. 11. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Tiera,

    I hope you try it. It’s really gives lashes that feathery look. :)

  12. 12. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Brenda,

    I highly recommend both this brand and Chanel’s Exceptionnel. While they perform differently, each creates a very distinct lash look.

    One great thing about Iconic is that it doesn’t clump!

  13. 13. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Lindsay,

    I think Lash Exact has shorter and stubbier teeth… I *have* tried Mascara basic. It’s a good basic (pardon the pun) mascara, but I prefer their Precise Volume version ’cause it gives great lash length.

  14. 14. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Marisol,

    I find it easier to use than Diorshow (I have an issue with the big brush head — gets stuff all over the place). I also think it smudges less. Regular Diorshow creates a bit more thickness, and drama, for sure, but this is really pretty for feathery, natural lashes.

  15. 15. KK said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    I too am not a fan of Dior mascara. I feel like its kinda over rated, sorta… it just does nothing for me….now their glosses are another thing! ;)

    Buuuttt, not get me wrong I am a sucker for mascara. My new obsession is Lancome hypnose. I have short lashes and my friend thought I had on false lashes with the hypnose…..I am sure I will be at sephora tomorrow trying the Iconic! I have ZERO will power! Mascara and glosses and the worst for me!

    Have you tried the Givenchy mascara with the funky brush? I am soo getting it tomorrow! My friend is in love with it!

    Hope you had a great day, and just think its almost already hump day!!

    xoxoo

  16. 16. Brittany said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    I’ve been seeing this on various blogs for the past couple weeks and each time I hear really good reviews. Too bad I’m in college and broke and can’t *quite* justify spending almost $30 on mascara. Ah well. Looks really nice though :)

  17. 17. Meaghan said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    I too am a mascara whore and while I like Dior (and mind you I have the regular one, the sephora black black exclusive one and the iconic mascara) i gotta say, save yourself the $ and go out and get yourself the Cover Girl lash Blast! I honestly *HATE* drugstore brand mascara but this stuff is pretty tough to beat. It doesn’t clump like most of Dior’s mascaras (Iconic is better on this front) and has the same awesome rubbery grippy thingies that Iconic does and it’s only $6 so you can get yourself a tube in black and brown! The only downfall to the Lash Blast over the Dior is that it doesn’t have that signature rose water scent…

    Now who else is ready for the premiere of 90210 and then The Hills!?!?

    Meaghans last blog post..MAC’s Starflash/ Lustre Twin Collection Review and FOTD

  18. 18. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi KK,

    Yah, Diorshow seems to be one of those mascaras that really divide people. I haven’t tried the new Givenchy mascara because I’m *terrified* of the brush. I can totally see myself poking my eye out!

  19. 19. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Brittany,

    There’s always good drugstore options. I’m going to try one from Neutrogena next, and I’ll let you know if it works!

  20. 20. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Meaghan,

    I tried lash blast and I wasn’t crazy about it. I have a hard time with the brush!

    The Hills last night was okay. I miss the “real” drama from the Laguna Beach days.

  21. 21. Lehea said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    I think I’ll actually steer clear of this one. I still haven’t used up my DiorShow. Voluminous is my current HG mascara, so I’ve been neglecting DiorShow. I feel you on the Givenchy one though. The wand’s pretty intimidating.

  22. 22. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Lehea,

    Voluminous is a FAB mascara. I love that one too. As you can tell I have a serious mascara obsession. :)

  23. 23. Shockingpink said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    It looks so natural, I like it!

  24. 24. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Shockingpink,

    Me too. I was really surprised by how much I liked it!

  25. 25. KK said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Well if I get brave and head to sephora tomorrow I will report back to ya!!

  26. 26. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    I totally want to go back to Sephora tomorrow. I was just there, uh, three days ago, and I am already jonsing to go back like the fiend that I am. I totally want to make a ruckus in the Stila section, ha ha ha!

  27. 27. Elena said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hey Karen,

    Your lashes look good here! I finally got around to trying Max Factor’s 2000 Calorie Mascara – that one is a masterpiece, I love it! You should try Neutrogena’s Healthy Volume Mascara, too, I really like that one just as much as the Max Factor.

    How’s the experimentation with Cult of Cherry going? :)

  28. 28. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hi Elena,

    Thanks, girlie! I have tried and reviewed Max Factor’s 2000 Calorie in the past. It’s great stuff, and cheap too. I have Healthy Volume on my list, and I can’t wait to try it!

    I’ve been really loving the Cult of Cherry lipsticks lately. Lightly Ripe is my new favorite daytime lipstick. Tomorrow if I’m feeling better (I am catching a cold) I will hopefully get to play with more eye looks.

    How have you been? Did you have a good day?

  29. 29. Meaghan said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Wow I am such a dork! I completely thought it was Monday and the Hills was on tonight too!!!

    Meaghans last blog post..MAC’s Starflash/ Lustre Twin Collection Review and FOTD

  30. 30. Karen said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    No worries, girl! I am sure it will be on 2,455 times before next week’s ep. Oh! There will be a special showing this weekend before the VMAs. Be there!

  31. 31. Elena said, on September 2nd, 2008:

    Hey Karen,

    I did have a pretty good day. :) I’m actually getting over food poisoning right now (fun! I know), so it feels nice to finally be feeling better.

    I’m sorry about your cold! Feel better soon. I’m sending some good wishes your way. :)

  32. 32. Eru said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    [FAQ mode ON]
    Dear Karen:
    I have Exceptionnel already. Do I need Iconic?
    Thanks,

    Eru :3.
    [FAQ mode OFF]
    :D
    PS: Have you checked the other colors? I’m thinking about getting Iconic in Blue, but I haven’t seen the shade yet…
    Hugs!

    Erus last blog post..New GHD Styler: Dark or Pure?

  33. 33. Karen B said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    Looks great!
    Do they have a waterproof version?

  34. 34. Ellery said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    Oooh, I’m always watching out for a new mascara.

    The other day I found a cheap £1.75 mascara I must have bought a few months ago, so I decided to try it and it’s sooo good for the price.

    I didn’t get a full picture of my lashes but you get the idea from this one. ^_^

    http://i35.tinypic.com/345ivlz.png

  35. 35. tokyostargirl said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    I have heard so many great things about Dior mascaras, but have yet to try any!

    Hope you got my email thanking you for the wordpress tips! You rock!

    tokyostargirls last blog post..Softymo – Nose Clean Pack

  36. 36. Erin said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    Nice Karen! Your lashes look super long!

  37. 37. Karen said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    Hi Elena,

    Oh no! I hope you’re feeling better. Food poisoning sucks. :(

    Have a good day today… I’m really glad we’re halfway through the week. I’m already ready for Friday!

  38. 38. Karen said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    {FAQ Mode ON}

    My dear Eru,

    Depends on what you’re looking for. Iconic is a completely different look. You could totally rock it though, as your lashes are naturally very beautiful. Iconic would give them an extra burst of day-friendly ooh lah lah!

    hugs,

    Karen

    {FAQ Mode OFF} ;)

    I haven’t checked out the other shades! I didn’t even know there was a blue!

  39. 39. Karen said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    Hi Karen B.,

    No, not that I know o. :( It’s pretty sturdy, though, and doesn’t smudge throughout the day.

  40. 40. Karen said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    Hi Ellery,

    Your lashes and your shadow look fantastic in this pic. What shades are you using? Love the blending, too!

  41. 41. Karen said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    Hi Tokyostargirl,

    I did get it! Glad to be of help, girlie!

  42. 42. Karen said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    Hi Erin,

    Thank ya! Are you a Dior fan, too?

  43. 43. Megan said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    This one is probably not dramatic enough for me to shell out that kind of money…I mean i have plenty of day mascaras that I love that are cheaper. How does it do with flaking? That’s my normal issue with Dioshow.

  44. 44. Karen B said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    hmm. Problem is with the rainy weather here in Belgium and my tendency to ride my bike… I think I’ll have to go for a waterproof mascara (I already had troubles with my Stile non-waterproof)

  45. 45. Ellery said, on September 3rd, 2008:

    Thank you! I used MAC Parrot all over, MAC Nile on the outer corner then Too Faced Jealous on the inside. I love that combination.

  46. 46. Victoria said, on September 5th, 2008:

    I am such a DiorShow fan, your post is just getting me more excited to try it out. Have you heard about the free trial being offered at counters? http://www.dior.com/pcd/International/JSP/Library/Full/full_L6.jsp?pTPL=1081&pLANG=engb&RUB=scene_4 You can fill out your info at that site and print out a coupon to bring to your local Dior counter.

    Victorias last blog post..Stand Up To Cancer

  47. 47. Erica said, on September 12th, 2008:

    This wand looks like Armani’s Maestro mascara wand. It also defines, separates and curls so effectively it looks like you’re wearing falsies! LUV it! I haven’t tried this one, but it looks like it may have the same effect. For someone with short, stumpy, but thick lashes I love that effect.

    Ericas last blog post..What’s in your cabinet? Part One

  48. 48. kat said, on November 4th, 2008:

    I really want to try this mascara…
    I’ve used Christian Dior mascara’s before and the best one I’VE tried is DIORSHOW but it expired soon after I started wearing it (it was originally my mums).
    I’M PROBABLY GONNA GET THIS ONE THO.
    It’s like 50 bucks here in Aus but oh well. Beauty costs!!!!

  49. 49. How Closely Do You Follow Makeup Expiration Guidelines?: Makeup and Beauty Blog: Makeup Reviews, Beauty Tips and Drugstore Beauty Finds said, on February 10th, 2009:

    [...] I don’t follow them to a “T”. I can’t bring myself to toss a $27 tube of Diorshow Iconic Mascara just because I’ve had it open for three [...]

< Older | Newer >

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv Enabled


© 2009 Makeup and Beauty Blog | Design By The Blog Studio