Maybe I’m too used to my gel liners, but I just can’t get the dark line I’m looking for. Probably better if you want a smudged look?
.-= veronica’s last blog post… Women in the world of gaming =-.
I love the idea of this, and the range of shades…but these colours look too familiar for my liking! I have 3 UD palettes and I’m pretty sure I have all these shades between them!
I would love to have this, I don’t have any urban decay and I know all the colors are the same just the names are different but this would be the one palette I would get.
Can’t WAIT to see the swatches! It’s sold out on the UD website, but I think I remember reading on Temptalia that this will be in Sephora in March or something. Is this true, Karen?
It’s a cute box, but after all the hyping up they did, it’s pretty lame that there isn’t a single new shade (and also that everything’s been renamed, to add an extra hassle for anyone who wants to repurchase anything).
That said, they are still nice shades, I wouldn’t be opposed to owning it – I just wish as much effort would’ve gone into the product as did the packaging.
*dies* There are only two or three shades out of that palette that I know I wouldn’t love to death — meaning there are thirteen or so I know I WOULD love to death! Being a broke student just rips my heart out when products like this come up. *reaches near hysteria* It’s Alice! I love and have always loved Alice, ever since I was [motions near my knee] yea high!
In other words, I cannot wait for swatches 😛 I almost want to pick it up and justify it as a “blog purchase,” but for some [awful, evil, strange] reason, I feel like perhaps saving up for tuition is more important.
I’m totally loving it, except for 2 things: UD openly said they aren’t original colors, just renamed colors from their core line. And I’m also not too thrilled about the $52 pricetag. I feel like it’s not really worth more than $30 to me.
If you can believe it or not…..the only shade that I will not be using from this palette is Alice :), I didn’t like the story and I don’t like the shade….what can I do 🙂
Celine says
Meh the other 2 Book of Shadows have all these colors. Sorry.
Kailey says
I ordered it at midnight on the 15th. Can’t wait to get it!!!
Stephanie Altoro says
would love to use Queen, Oraculum and Mad Hatter together.
veronica says
Love, except I’m not a huge fan of the Zero liner!
HC says
Wow, you are the first person I’ve heard who does not love the Zero liner! I would looove to know why!
Jenna says
I’m a fan of Zero but I don’t understand why it’s in EVERY palette UD puts out. They should change it up a bit…
veronica says
Maybe I’m too used to my gel liners, but I just can’t get the dark line I’m looking for. Probably better if you want a smudged look?
.-= veronica’s last blog post… Women in the world of gaming =-.
Rori says
I love the idea of this, and the range of shades…but these colours look too familiar for my liking! I have 3 UD palettes and I’m pretty sure I have all these shades between them!
julie says
I only have one UD palette, so even if I have a couple of dups, I’d still be getting some new ones! Can’t wait!
Megan says
I want this SOOOO bad because UD has such good shadows but they are sold out 🙁
Sure hope they make some more so I can get my hands on one!!!!
Darci says
I would love to have this, I don’t have any urban decay and I know all the colors are the same just the names are different but this would be the one palette I would get.
Ari says
Can’t WAIT to see the swatches! It’s sold out on the UD website, but I think I remember reading on Temptalia that this will be in Sephora in March or something. Is this true, Karen?
HC says
I CAN’T WAIT FOR YOUR REVIEW!
I’m waiting on my shipment right now. Said it got shipped today. What’s up w/ the slow-ness? I’m antsy!
Alcy says
It’s a cute box, but after all the hyping up they did, it’s pretty lame that there isn’t a single new shade (and also that everything’s been renamed, to add an extra hassle for anyone who wants to repurchase anything).
That said, they are still nice shades, I wouldn’t be opposed to owning it – I just wish as much effort would’ve gone into the product as did the packaging.
Rae says
*dies* There are only two or three shades out of that palette that I know I wouldn’t love to death — meaning there are thirteen or so I know I WOULD love to death! Being a broke student just rips my heart out when products like this come up. *reaches near hysteria* It’s Alice! I love and have always loved Alice, ever since I was [motions near my knee] yea high!
In other words, I cannot wait for swatches 😛 I almost want to pick it up and justify it as a “blog purchase,” but for some [awful, evil, strange] reason, I feel like perhaps saving up for tuition is more important.
Y’know. Just a little 😉
Sarah says
Some of the colors are drastic, but wearable if blended right. Not my favorite but I still think its pretty.
marisol says
I am not too into it but didn’t it sell out on the site?
Alexzandra says
This is very cute, but I hate to buy a palette unless I’m sure that I’ll wear 75% of the shades, and I’m just not quite there yet with this one.
K says
Okay, with Johnny Depp alone as colorful as he is in that movie, I expected more. This is so disappointing.
scarlettholly says
yes, I really really want this!! am staking out sephora until they show up… 😉
Stacie says
Meh. This one got a lot of hype, but I’m sure I have most of these colors. Some new/limited edition shades would have been nice.
Mariah says
I’m totally loving it, except for 2 things: UD openly said they aren’t original colors, just renamed colors from their core line. And I’m also not too thrilled about the $52 pricetag. I feel like it’s not really worth more than $30 to me.
amy says
Curiouser and Underland are my favourite colours in the palette. The pop up packaging is nice touch to it too. I am suck I sucker for cool packaging.
diane says
Kandee Johnson just did a tutorial with it 😀
Tavia says
If you can believe it or not…..the only shade that I will not be using from this palette is Alice :), I didn’t like the story and I don’t like the shade….what can I do 🙂
lexi says
I would have bought this if I didn’t already have the Ammo and Get Baked palettes. It breaks my heart because i HEART Alice BIG TIME!!!